Saturday, November 21
Shadow

11 Years On, Bargari Sacrilege and Kotkapura-Behbal Kalan Firing Cases Still Await Trial: Charges Not Framed in Any of 5 Cases

Raghbir Singh Brar

Faridkot

From the theft of a Saroop in June 2015 to the transfer of trials to Chandigarh in 2026, the cases have seen multiple Commissions, SITs, CBI probe and court stays, but no trial has begun yet.

1. Introduction

More than 11 years after a series of incidents in Faridkot district shook Punjab, the five interconnected criminal cases, three relating to alleged sacrilege and two relating to police firing, remain at the pre-trial stage.

As per court records and media reports, charges have not been framed against any accused in any of the five cases as of October 2026. A charge-sheet (challan) is only the police version of events. Framing of charges by a court is the stage at which a trial formally begins.

This report is based on FIRs, Commission reports, SIT reports as reported in the public domain, and court orders as reported by various medias.

2. The Three Alleged Sacrilege Cases

Case 1: Alleged Theft of Bir – FIR No. 63, 2 June 2015

  • Allegation: On 1 June 2015, a Bir (Saroop) of Sri Guru Granth Sahib was allegedly stolen from Gurdwara Singh Sabha, Burj Jawahar Singh Wala, Faridkot.
  • Police Action: FIR was registered. The Bir has not been recovered, as per reports.
  • Protest: On 11 June 2015, protesters marched to the local police station. Police used force. Reports said 17 persons were injured.

Case 2: Alleged Derogatory Posters – FIR No. 117, 25 September 2015

  • Allegation: Handwritten posters with alleged derogatory references to Sri Guru Granth Sahib were found pasted in Burj Jawahar Singh Wala and Bargari villages.
  • Police Action: FIR registered. Posters were seized.

Case 3: Alleged Scattering of Torn Pages – FIR No. 128, 12 October 2015

  • Allegation: On the morning of 12 October 2015, over 100 torn pages (angs) of Sri Guru Granth Sahib were found scattered near the Gurdwara at Bargari village.
  • Public Reaction: The incident triggered widespread protests across Punjab. A dharna was started at Kotkapura.

Legal Note: The three cases are presently pending before the Court of Chief Judicial Magistrate, Chandigarh. Proceedings are stayed following orders of the Punjab and Haryana High Court (11 March 2024) and the Supreme Court (29 April 2025), as reported.

3. The Two Police Firing Cases – 14 October 2015

A) Kotkapura Firing

  • What Happened (as per records): On 14 October 2015, police action took place at Light Point Chowk, Kotkapura, to disperse protesters.
  • Reported Injuries: One protester, Ajit Singh, allegedly sustained a bullet injury. Reports said 60+ persons were injured.

B) Behbal Kalan Firing

  • What Happened (as per records): A few hours later, on the same day, police opened fire at protesters at Behbal Kalan.
  • Deaths (Confirmed): Two protesters died: Krishan Bhagwan Singh (45) and Gurjit Singh (27).
  • Legal Status: The families allege the firing was unprovoked. The police version at the time described it as action to control the crowd. The matter is sub-judice and no court has yet decided on culpability.

4. Investigation Timeline – Chronological

2015-2016:

  • 21 Oct 2015: First SIT under ADGP Iqbal Preet Singh Sahota arrested two persons. That line of investigation did not lead to conviction.
  • Nov 2015: Justice Zora Singh Commission constituted by the then State Government.
  • 3 Nov 2015: State Government transferred the three sacrilege cases to CBI. CBI registered them on 13 Nov 2015.
  • 30 Nov 2015: SIT under IG Ranbir Singh Khattra formed for Kotkapura firing.

2017-2019:

  • 2017: Justice Ranjit Singh Commission report submitted. As per reports, it made observations regarding the then political leadership and police officials. The observations were not a judicial finding of guilt.
  • 2018: CBI filed closure reports in the three sacrilege cases, stating insufficient evidence. The State Government took back the cases from CBI.
  • Sept 2018: New SIT under ADGP Prabodh Kumar formed, with IG Kunwar Vijay Pratap Singh as investigator.

2021:

  • 9 April 2021: Punjab and Haryana High Court quashed the investigation conducted by the Kunwar Vijay Pratap Singh-led SIT, observing it was biased. A new SIT under ADGP L.K. Yadav was constituted in May 2021.

2022-2023:

  • Feb 2023: The L.K. Yadav SIT filed a challan running into about 7,000 pages in the Kotkapura firing case.
  • 28 Feb 2023: Supreme Court transferred the three sacrilege cases from Faridkot to Chandigarh.
  • April 2023: Supplementary challans were filed in the firing case.

2024-2026:

  • 31 May 2024: Behbal Kalan firing case transferred from Faridkot to Chandigarh.
  • 11 March 2024 and 29 April 2025: Proceedings in sacrilege cases stayed by High Court and Supreme Court respectively.
  • 9 April 2026: Punjab and Haryana High Court transferred Kotkapura firing trials to Chandigarh. For the first time, both firing cases are in one city.
  • July-Aug 2026: Behbal Kalan SIT, as per reports, revisited the site and recorded statements. Status reports were filed in sealed cover before the Chandigarh court on 1 Aug 2026.
  • 3 Sept 2026: Accused persons appeared before Chandigarh District Court, some via video-conference, as per reports.
  • 17 Oct 2026: Next date of hearing fixed.

5. Who Are the Accused? (As Per Charge-Sheets, Not Convicted)

Important Legal Disclaimer: Being named in a charge-sheet or FIR does not mean a person is guilty. Under Indian law, every accused is presumed innocent until proven guilty by a court.

In Sacrilege Cases:

  • As per charge-sheets reported in media, Dera Sacha Sauda chief Gurmeet Ram Rahim and several Dera followers have been named as accused. They have denied the allegations, as per their statements in court proceedings.

In Firing Cases:

  • As per charge-sheets, former Deputy Chief Minister Sukhbir Singh Badal, former DGP Sumedh Singh Saini, former IG Paramraj Singh Umranangal, and former SSP Charanjit Sharma have been named as accused. All are on bail. They have denied wrongdoing and have termed the cases as political, as per their public statements.
  • Proceedings against former Chief Minister Parkash Singh Badal were closed following his death in April 2023.

6. Other Related Deaths (On Record)

  • Mohinderpal Singh Bittu, an accused in one of the sacrilege cases, died in Nabha jail in 2019 after being attacked by inmates.
  • Pradeep Singh, a Dera follower and an accused, was shot dead in Faridkot in November 2022. The case is separate.

These deaths are mentioned only for factual completeness.

7. Current Status as of November 2026

CaseCourtStatus
FIR 63 – Bir TheftCJM, ChandigarhStayed, charges not framed
FIR 117 – PostersCJM, ChandigarhStayed, charges not framed
FIR 128 – Bargari PagesCJM, ChandigarhStayed, charges not framed
Kotkapura FiringSessions Court, ChandigarhChallan filed, charges not framed
Behbal Kalan FiringSessions Court, ChandigarhInvestigation reported as pending, charges not framed

8. Why Has Justice Been Delayed?

Legal experts and media analyses cite these reasons, not as findings but as procedural factors:

  1. Multiple Agencies: CBI, 4-5 different SITs, and Commissions investigated at different times.
  2. Court Transfers: Cases moved from Faridkot to Chandigarh on orders of Supreme Court / High Court.
  3. Legal Challenges: Multiple petitions challenging SITs, challans, and jurisdiction.
  4. Stays: High Court and Supreme Court stays have halted trial court proceedings.
  5. Political Sensitivity: The cases have been a major issue in every Punjab election since 2017.

9. Conclusion

On 14 October 2026, the 11th anniversary was observed at Kotkapura and Behbal Kalan. Families of the deceased, as reported, continue to demand a time-bound trial.

The State Government has stated in public that it is committed to ensuring justice. The accused have stated that they will cooperate with investigation and that they expect acquittal.

As of today, the judicial process is still at the pre-trial stage. No court has held any person guilty or innocent in these five cases.

No originality is claimed.The report has been compiled for the information of the Public from various reports in the media and information in public domain. File Photos usedtaken by the reporter.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *